Buying a new computer

It's time I replaced my laptop. My Toshiba Tecra 9000 is starting to suffer. It's a 1.2Ghz PIIIM with 768Mb of Ram. It originally came with Win2K, I went through upgrade hell waiting for drivers as XP came along. Its been to three continents, it travels over two hundred miles a day, and spends a couple hours every day in my rucksack. I don't think it will take Vista as it really needs it S3 display drivers and the Vista upgrade assistant reports them as incompatible. More telling it just won't do rendering at any decent pace. It struggles with Sim City 4.

But what to buy? Does that just sound like the wrong question? It is. Lets start with some requirements.

  • Form factor
    • Weight is less of an issue, as I currently have two batteries and anything I buy will be lighter. Both batteries are fading so give me a total of 2 hours total.
    • Build quality and durability is important. It's got to last a tough lifetime, it doesn't have to be a ToughBook though. Just five years of use, not abuse.
  • Vista
    • There's a whole new host of search functionality I can't wait to get my hands on. For years I've played with an application but what lets it down is having a corpus to work against.
    • It looks pretty.
  • More power
    • I use VS2005 a lot. I wait for VS2005 to compile a lot. More CPU power please, oh and can I have a 7200rpm drive instead of a 5400rpm too.
  • Better screen real estate
    • Did I mention VS2005. This is a good example of an app that likes to pack in more onto the screen, and basically I'd like to run a higher resolution (although I may up the DPI if it's too small).
  • Not make my RSI any worse.
    • I don't have an RSI condition, at least it's not been diagnosed. I do have a bone spur on the back of each of my hands, and my wrists can hurt when I use my laptop in an awkward position. That all said, I'd like to be able to use a computer in an alternate configuration. Maybe a pen interface.

So what is there

The tablet element is the part that reduces the field quite nicely, there are only

Asus R1 Tablet PC, Fujitsu LifeBook T4215, HP Pavilion tx1000z, Lenovo (IBM) ThinkPad X60 Tablet PC, Toshiba Portege M400, Compaq TC4400 Tablet PC, Toshiba Portege R400

So lets reduce some from the list straight off.

Toshiba Portege R400 - not enough CPU power, its a Core Duo U2500 1.2 GHz

HP Pavilion tx1000z - Build is mostly plastic, some flex in parts

Fujitsu LifeBook T4215 - Dodgy keyboard

Now lets consider the screen

Compaq TC4400 Tablet PC - only 1024x768 but has T7200 2.0GHz

Asus R1 Tablet PC - 13.3" wide-screen at 1280x800 WXGA and only T5500 1.6GHz CPU. Reports suggest lots of Vista driver issues.

Which brings us to CPU

Lenovo (IBM) ThinkPad X60 Tablet PC - L2500 1.83GHz and 1400x1050 SXGA+. This is tempting, build quality is high, and performance is close.

And that only leaves

Toshiba Portege M400 available as M400-146 with 1400x1050 SXGA+ and T7200 2.0GHz.

But there is just one minor problem, there could be a successor to Toshiba M400 coming...

Comments (2) -

http://
http://
4/10/2007 9:19:22 PM #


Hi Alan,

Just read with interest your post on looking for a new laptop as I am in a similar predicament looking to upgrade my two and a half year old Portege M200.

My take on it is it pretty similar to yours with respect to the M400 being the the most likely candidate.

Interestingly the US Toshiba site (www.toshibadirect.com) got a processor refresh to 2.3Ghz Core 2 Duo.

Meanwhile in the UK we're waiting for the processor refresh hopefully with Vista ultimate and hopefully coming sometime!

As for the possibility of a successor to the M400, I've not heard of anything and suspect the R400 will be the flagship Portege tablet for some time - but you never can tell. Other than a better graphics chipset (which is the same as in the R400 anyway), I'm not sure what else of significance they would pack in.

One of the best features to me of the M400 is the media bay which enables an onboard DVD player (missing from my M200) and more importantly the chance to add a second hard drive for running virtual machines.

  
          

http://
http://
6/21/2007 8:34:12 PM #


Looks like direct2dell.com/.../15193.aspx">Dell are going to be bringing out a convertible tablet later this year

Could be a contender?





  
          

Add comment

  Country flag


  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading